← Back to the latest articles
QUESTION 113Politics, Institutions & Power

By NOW IN QUESTION EditorialSourcing & correctionsReport an error

Trump's 60 Minutes Immigration Remarks: What Should Years of Residence Count For?

What Trump said about deportations and how he responded to talk of amnesty

Donald Trump raised the possibility of working with Democrats on immigration and cited people who had lived and worked in the US for years. He then ruled out amnesty. What changed, and how should years of residence matter when a government decides whom to remove?

In a CBS 60 Minutes interview aired on November 8, 2026, President Donald Trump said his administration's deportation drive may have been too harsh. He raised the case of people who had lived and worked in the United States for ten or fifteen years and expressed interest in reaching a deal with Democrats. The next day, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told reporters that he and Trump had yet to discuss any concrete policy changes, the Associated Press reported. Trump himself told reporters on November 9 that there would be no amnesty, according to The Australian.

On November 9, third-party snapshots of US X trends repeatedly displayed “Amnesty” and “60 Minutes.” Mediaite reported that a White House rapid-response account replied on X to a post characterizing the remarks as an amnesty proposal, saying that the word had not been used in the exchange. Rolling Stone cited English-language posts from a commentator who took the remarks as a sign of a possible retreat. The posts show how differently people heard the same interview.

What changed after Trump's interview?

Date, US Eastern time What happened
November 6 CBS recorded the interview following the midterm elections.
November 8 CBS aired the interview. Trump raised the possibility of working with Democrats and singled out some long-term residents.
November 9 Mullin said that he and Trump had yet to discuss specific changes. Trump told reporters there would be no amnesty.

In this debate, “amnesty” is a political label often used for some form of legal relief for people living in the country without authorization. An enforcement priority, a temporary reprieve and a route to permanent status would have different consequences. Mullin also discussed Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, which offers temporary protection to some people brought to the US as children. He said a route to permanent legal status for that group would be a matter for Congress.

The interview and follow-up remarks establish no new application process or change to anyone's status or deadlines. If lawmakers or the administration publish a proposal, the details to look for are who qualifies, what the measure grants, who can put it into effect and when it takes effect.

What difference should years of residence make?

Uniform enforcement has a claim to fairness. People in similar legal circumstances can expect the same rule to apply, regardless of who handles their case. A residence-based exception raises an awkward question of its own. If eligibility starts after ten years, what justifies treating someone who arrived a month earlier differently from someone who arrived a month later?

Yet the consequences of removal can differ even when the underlying legal circumstances are similar. Over time, people may become caregivers, raise children or take on commitments that others depend on. Work and tax payments are ways to describe those ties. If they become the only measures, an unpaid caregiver or a person who cannot work can appear less connected than they really are.

How should the state weigh obligations that have accumulated over time? Any exception needs a public reason, a consistent standard for applying it and a way for people to challenge errors. Those safeguards matter both to people whose lives depend on a decision and to those who want the government to explain why similar-looking cases had different outcomes.

For the separate question of who shapes policy inside the White House, see our article on Stephen Miller's appointment as chief of staff.


References

Information checked November 10, 2026 (Japan time).

SHARE

Share this article

Carry the question into another conversation.

DISCUSSION

Discuss this question

Write in Japanese or English. Comments are translated automatically and shared across both versions of the article.

0/2000 characters

Loading comments…